Free cookie consent management tool by TermsFeed How Recruitment Commission Structures Impact Your Lifetime Earnings | Hypha Recruit
Image

How Your Commission Structure Could Cost You £500,000 Over Your Career

  • rec 2 rec


Time Is The Real Currency In Recruitment

We talk so much about money.

But time is the real currency.

Time to save for a house.
Time to clear your mortgage.
Time to build investments.
Time to retire earlier.
Time to actually enjoy the life you’re working for.

In recruitment, your commission structure determines how much of that time you own.

And over a 15–20 year career, the maths becomes uncomfortable.


Same Billing. Completely Different Outcomes.

Let’s take a consultant billing £250,000 per year.

That’s roughly £20,833 per month.

Now let’s compare three structures.


1. A Poor Scheme (Common in Corporate Environments)

Example:

  • £5,000 monthly threshold (no commission below this)

  • £10,000 – £15,000 @ 10%

  • £15,000 – £20,000 @ 15%

  • £20,000+ @ 20%

At £20,833 per month:

  • First £5,000 = no commission

  • £5,000 @10% = £500

  • £5,000 @15% = £750

  • £833 @20% ≈ £167

Monthly commission ≈ £1,417
Annual commission ≈ £17,000

Blended rate: 6.8%

At £250k billing, you’re effectively earning less than 7% of what you generate.

This type of structure protects company margin aggressively.

It feels manageable early on.

Over a career, it’s extremely expensive.


2. A Mid-Level Tiered Structure

Example:

  • 10% up to £30k

  • 20% up to £50k

  • 30% thereafter

At £250,000 billing:

Annual commission typically lands between
£43,000 – £50,000

Blended rate: 17% – 20%

Better.

But still heavily weighted toward business protection over consultant upside.


3. A Strong Performance-Led Model

Example: Threshold + Accelerator Model

  • £3,500 monthly threshold

  • 20% on billing above threshold

  • Quarterly kickers:

    • £35k = +2.5% uplift

    • £50k = +5% uplift

    • £75k = +7.5% uplift

    • £100k = +10% uplift

At £250,000 billing:

Annual commission ≈ £62,000

Blended rate: 24.8%

Now you’re approaching a genuinely performance-led structure.

You’re keeping roughly a quarter of what you generate.

That difference compounds fast.


Now Stretch It Over 15 Years

Assume consistent £250k billing.

Poor Scheme

£17,000 per year
Blended: 6.8%
15 years = £255,000

Mid-Level Scheme

£46,000 average
Blended: ~18.5%
15 years = £690,000

Strong Scheme

£62,000 per year
Blended: 24.8%
15 years = £930,000

Difference between poor and strong over 15 years:

£675,000

That’s life-changing.

That’s:

  • A house bought and paid off quickly 

  • Financial independence

  • Early retirement runway

  • Or simply decades with less financial pressure


Why This Matters

Commission structures shape behaviour.

High thresholds punish slow starts.
Low blended rates flatten ambition.
Quarterly accelerators reward consistency.
Retro models reward performance properly.

Corporate recruitment firms often operate tighter, margin-protective commission structures.

They optimise for predictability and shareholder return.

Many independent firms that genuinely value retention and high performance build structures that accelerate earlier and reward output properly.

On top of better commission many of our clients also reward performers with annual bonuses and in the long term profit share. 

Over 15–20 years, that difference compounds dramatically.


The Real Question

It isn’t:

“What’s the top percentage?”

It’s:

“What’s my blended rate at my realistic billing level?”

Because that blended rate determines:

  • When you buy your house

  • How quickly you build wealth

  • How long you need to work for 

  • How much stress you carry

Recruitment isn’t a one-year sprint.

It’s a career.

And over 15–20 years, your commission structure decides how much of your lifetime you’re properly rewarded for.

Author

Vicky Wilson

Director Rec2Rec Specialist for Brighton, Sussex & Surrey

Resource Hub.

Why Insight Matters

Don’t you just love some clients… and, well, others not so much? As rec2rec specialists we see behind the door of lots of recruitment businesses ev
  • rec 2 rec

Loyal to a Fault

Loyal to a Fault What you don’t know, you don’t know. And staying loyal can quietly cost you. I spoke to a candidate recently whose situation I

Goldilocks and the Three Trainee Recruiters

GOLDILOCKS AND THE THREE GRAD RECRUITERS Curiosity, caution, and why self-awareness decides who gets hired The original Goldilocks story was n
  • work
  • rec 2 rec

A Recruiter’s Cheat List: How to Check You’re Joining the Right Team

A Recruiter’s Cheat List: How to Check You’re Joining the Right Team Most recruiters don’t fail because they lack ability. They fail because they
  • rec 2 rec

When the Truth Is a Given, Everyone Wins

When the Truth Is a Given, Everyone Wins How working with a rec2rec unlocks better hiring outcomes by disarming both candidate and client Let’s
  • rec 2 rec

“I’ve Heard Bad Things About X Company”

“I’ve Heard Bad Things About X Company…” A statement I hear often, and one that too often closes the door on opportunity. To be honest, it’s a bit
  • news

Let’s Buy a Land Cruiser, Recruiters, Get Involved!

I’m sure many of you have heard Simon Sinek talk about connecting to your why in business. After reading his books, I felt compelled to take action on
  • rec 2 rec

Decoding Success: Questioning should be in your DNA

Every recruiter develops habits and behaviours that shape their career. For graduates entering the industry, the learning curve can feel steep — recru
  • rec 2 rec

The Subtle Art of Influence in Recruitment

Recruitment is often misunderstood. On the surface, it can look transactional: a job is open, a candidate is submitted, an interview is ar
  • news
  • work
  • rec 2 rec

How to Launch Your Career into Executive Search – Even if You’re Not from Recruitment

How to Launch Your Career into Executive Search – Even if You’re Not from Recruitment Why the Space Sector is the Perfect Example of What’s Pos
  • for clients
  • rec 2 rec

Male Leadership in Recruitment: Navigating the Shift from Toxic to Positive Masculinity

Male Leadership in Recruitment: Navigating the Shift from Toxic to Positive Masculinity The world of recruitment has long been shaped by high-e
  • rec 2 rec

Make or Break: Graduates getting into Recruitment

Make or Break: How Trainees & Graduates Can Get Into Recruitment Breaking into recruitment isn’t easy—competition is fierce, and first impressions